Newzbin block will not stop online piracy

The UK high court’s decision to instruct BT to block access to Newzbin, a website that links to allegedly illegal copyright material, will do little to dampen either online piracy or emotional debate about it.

BT said in a statement, “This is a helpful judgement, which provides clarity on this complex issue. It clearly shows that rights holders need to prove their claims and convince a judge to make a court order. BT has consistently said that rights holders need to take this route (through the courts). We will return to court after the summer to explain what kind of order we believe is appropriate.”

BT and TalkTalk are appealing an earlier decision to reject their appeal against their loss of a judicial review to set aside parts of the UK’s controverisal Digital Economy Act that deal with online piracy.

Reacting to the Newzbin decision Peter Bradwell, copyright campaigner at the Open Rights Group said, “Website blocking is pointless and dangerous. These judgements won’t work to stop infringement or boost creative industries. And there are serious risks of legitimate content being blocked and service slowdown.

“If the goal is boosting creators’ ability to make money from their work then we need to abandon these technologically naive measures, focus on genuine market reforms, and satisfy unmet consumer demand.”

ISPA secretary general Nicholas Lansman said, “ISPA has long maintained that this is an issue that rights holders should seek to address in court, rather than through voluntary means, and today’s ruling should go some way to offering clarity on what is a complex area.”

Landsman said he was concerned about over-blocking, the ease of circumvention and increased use of encryption. These were ” widely-recognised”, which meany blocking would not stop online copyright infringement.

“Rather, as the government-commissioned Hargreaves Review recently found, there should be more focus on offering innovative, fully-licensed content services to give consumers what they are clearly demanding,” he said.

Pirate Party UK, which campaigns for an “open internet”, said on Twitter, “Hollywood’s win in the Newzbin case is a disaster for ordinary UK internet users. This could open the internet censorship floodgates.”

The decision comes less than a week after EMI’s former COO of new music and president of digital business, Douglas Merrill, reportedly claimed that EMI’s own research showed the peer to peer downloaders were in fact the music company’s best clients.

According to reports by ComputerWorld Australia, the TorrentFreak blog and Cory Doctorow on the Boing Boing blog, Merrill, a former Google CIO, said they used illegal download sites to sample music before buying the CDs of those they liked best.

The Newzbin case relates to videos and films, rather than to music, but the trade bodies that represent both industries have worked together in the past, notably on the Anti-counterfeiting Trade Agreement (Acta).

According to a new assessment of the legality of Acta under European law, “Acta was controversial both in terms of the process and the substance of the neotations. The decision to maintain secrecy (from October 2007) until the release of draft text in mid-2010 was to prove a significant handicap to public understanding and support of the treaty.”

The study, by the policy department of the European Commission’s external policies department,  found that the provisions against online piracy had been very watered down from the original proposals.

However, it found that ACTA extended criminal measures of indirect commercial benefit. This may contradict the European parliament’s position that acts “carried out by private users for personal and not-for-profit purposes” were to be excluded, it said.

The assessment also said there is no “three-strikes” provision that calls for internet service providers to cut off internet access to infringers, but ISPs are required to provide information about subscribers to rightsholders on request.

“However, this provision is not mandatory. There is no requirement for takedown notices. However, the normal producdures for injunctions and provisional measures will be applied in the digital environment,” it said.


1 Comment

Filed under Uncategorized

One response to “Newzbin block will not stop online piracy

  1. Most people I know use pirate sites simply because they can leave stuff running overnight to download due to limited internet access where they live. If it was easy to buy and download stuff then they would. Its time to get some fast fat pipes and get the show on the road.
    I agree, you can’t stop pirates. But you can make an alternative more attractive. But first, we need the infrastructure, fibre fed internet access not this copper dribble.
    We then need the obsolete music industry to be dragged kicking and screaming into this century.
    And we need politicians who understand physics and the needs and desires of the people who pay for their long summer vacations.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s